With respect to the argument regarding aliens who receive the designated public benefits, detroit lions national football league full over print shirt but may nonetheless be a net benefit to the U.S. Government or society, neither the Act nor the case law requires DHS
detroit lions national football league full over print shirt
an occupant of almshouses for want of means of support. This commenter indicated that DHS’s historical argument—that the late 19th century history and meaning are irrelevant detroit lions national football league full over print shirt because the wide array of limited-purpose public benefits now available did not exist at the time—was historically inaccurate. The commenter noted that contemporaneous sources and historical studies reveal that throughout the 19th century’s governments, including the Federal Government, provided limited public assistance short of institutionalization. Additionally, the commenter indicated that even if limited-purpose public benefits had not been available, the argument is immaterial because such an expansion would not change the meaning of the term set out in the 1882 Act.
In fact, according to the commenter, Congress has declined to change its original meaning of the term. With respect to the commenter’s arguments about the Immigration Act of 1882, the conclusions that the commenter draws from the funding mechanism in that Act appear to be largely unsupported. The commenter assumes, without articulating any basis for the assumption, that under the Immigration Act of 1882 aliens who received assistance through the fund could not also be public charges. DHS has no reason to believe that assumption is correct. But even if the Immigration Act of 1882 could be read as suggesting that an alien can rely on public funds for support without becoming a public charge, DHS is unaware of any binding case law requiring DHS to interpret the term “public charge” in this manner. And regardless, Congress has since amended the public charge ground of inadmissibility multiple times over the course of more than a century.